Aghvank Architecture in Scientific Literature
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54338/27382656-2024.7-02Keywords:
Artsakh, Bun Aghvank, Aghvank architecture, Sudagilan, Mamrukh, NyugdiAbstract
In recent decades, articles on Aghvank architecture have been published in scientific literature, showcasing notable differences from materials published before the 1970s. These newer publications present conflicting results and conclusions, reflecting diverse scientific approaches. As a result, the Azerbaijani scientific community portrays the entire Christian culture of Artsakh, particularly its architecture, as a component of the Aghvan heritage. This paper comprehensively reviews existing scientific materials on Aghvank architecture, spanning publications from both the Soviet and post-Soviet eras, as well as compares the articles authored by Azerbaijani scholars with those that have been written in foreign languages and published in periodicals. After conducting research, it is evident that Azerbaijani historians have increasingly attempted to claim the Christian culture and architecture of Artsakh as their own over the past 40 years. This has led to a loss of objectivity and scientific approach towards existing materials and methods. The study aimed to show the dynamics of the "scientific study" of Azerbaijani architecture, the editing of the "new history" of the medieval culture and architecture of Aghvank in the Caucasus in recent decades, to highlight the main contradictions evident in the results of research by Azerbaijani and foreign scientists. Today, in the context of the occupation of the entire territory of Artsakh and its architectural heritage, such a discovery is becoming increasingly important.
Downloads
References
N.Y. Marr, Trudy Komissii po izucheniyu plemennogo sostava naseleniya SSSR i sopredel'nykh stran. USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, 1922 (in Russian).
I.P. Shcheblykin, Pamyatniki Azerbaydzhanskogo zodchestva epokhi Nizami. AzFAN, Baku, 1943 (in Russian).
L.S. Bretanitskiy, B.V. Veymarn, Iskusstvo Azerbaydzhana IV- XVIII vekov. Iskusstvo, Moscow, 1976 (in Russian).
S.A. Dadashev, M.A. Useinov, Arkhitektura Azerbaydzhana: Epokha Nizami, sbornik statey. State architectural publishing house, Moscow, 1947 (in Russian).
M.A. Useinov, S.A. Dadashev, Arkhitektura Azerbaydzhana. USSR Academy of Architecture, Moscow, 1948 (in Russian).
M.A. Useinov, S.A. Dadashev, Arkhitektura Azerbaydzhana III-XIXvv. USSR Academy of Architecture, Moscow, 1948 (in Russian).
K.V. Trever, Ocherki po istorii i kul'ture Kavkazskoy Albanii IVv do n.e.-VII v.n.e. USSR Academy of Architecture, Leningrad, Moscow, 1959 (in Russian).
R.M. Vaydov, Rannesrednevekovoye gorodishche Sudagylan (Mingechaur). KSIIMK, 54, 1954 (in Russian).
A G. Abramyan, Deshifrovka nadpisey kavkazskikh agvan․ Yerevan State University, Yerevan, 1964 (in Russian).
S. Karapetian, Armenian lapidary inscriptions of Boon-Aghvank. Publishing House "Gitutyun" of the National Academy of Sciences of RA, Yerevan, 1997 (in Armenian).
S. Jalalyants, A Trip to Great Armenia. DALL, Yerevan, 2016 (in Armenian).
A.V. Salamzade, Arkhitektura Azerbaydzhana XVI-XIX vv. Academy of Sciences of the Azerbaijan SSR, Baku, 1964 (in Russian).
N.V. Baranov, Y.S. Yaralov, A.V. Bunin, B.V. Veymarn, A.V. Ikonnikov, O.Kh. Khalpakhch'yan, etc., Vseobshchaya istoriya arkhitektury v 12 tomakh. Izdatel'stvo Literatury po stroitel'stvu, Moscow, (1966-1977) (in Russian).
M.A. Useinov, L.S. Bretanitsky, A.V. Salamzade, Arkhitektura Azerbaydzhana, 6, in: Y.S. Yaralov, B.V. Veymarn, V.A. Lavrov, A.M. Pribytkova, M.A. Useinov, O.Kh. Khalpakhch'yan (eds.), Vseobshchaya istoriya arkhitektury, vol. 8. Izdatel'stvo Literatury po stroitel'stvu, Moscow, 1969 (in Russian).
R.B. Geushev, O konfessional'no-etnicheskoy prinadlezhnosti Gandzasarskogo monastyrya. Material'naya kul'tura Azerbaydzhana, 7, 1973, 366-368 (in Russian).
R.B. Geushev, Khristianstvo v Kavkazskoy Albanii: Doctoral thesis, Tbilisi, 1978 (in Russian).Available at: https://dzurdzuki.com/download/geyushev-r-hristianstvo-v-kavkazskoj-albanii-1978/․ Accessed on June 20, 2024.
V.A. Shnirel'man, Voyny pamyati: mify, identichnost' i politika v Zakavkaz'ye. Akademkniga, Moscow, 2003 (in Russian).
A.L. Yakobson, Gandzasar (pamyatnik armyanskogo zodchestva XIII v.).Sovetakan Grokh, Yerevan, 1987 (in Russian).
A.L. Yakobson, Iz istorii Armyanskogo srednevekovogo zodchestva (Gandzasarskiy monastyr' XIII v.)․ Academy of Sciences of the Armenian SSR, Yerevan, 1991 (in Russian).
G.G. Mamedova, 'Kul'tovoye zodchestvo Kavkazskoy Albanii IV-XIVvv։ Doctoral thesis, Azerbaydzhanskiy inzhenerno-stroitel'nyy universitet, Baku, 1997 (in Russian).
G.G. Mamedova, Zodchestvo Kavkazskoy Albanii. Chashyoglu, Baku, 2004 (in Russian). Available at: http://web2.anl.az:81/read/page.php?bibid=17267&pno=2. Accessed on June 10, 2024.
A.T. Salimova, Tvorcheskiye korni vozniknoveniya kul'tovo-ritual'noy arkhitektury Kavkazskoy Albanii։ PhD thesis, Azerbaydzhanskiy inzhenerno-stroitel'nyy universitet Baku, 1988 (in Russian). Available at: https://tekhnosfera.com/view/385037/a#?page=1․ Accessed on March 24, 2024.
F.J. Mamedova, Politicheskaya istoriya i istoricheskaya geografiya Kavkazskoy Albanii (III v. do n. e.-VIII v. n. e). Elm, Baku, 1986 (in Russian).
A.A. Akopyan, P.M. Muradyan, K.N. Yuzbashyan, K izucheniyu istorii Kavkazskoy Albanii (po povodu knigi F. Mamedovoy "Politicheskaya istoriya i istoricheskaya geografiya Kavkazskoy Albanii (III v. do n. e. - VIII v. n. e.)". Historical and Philological Journal, Yerevan, 3, 1987, 166-189.
F.J. Mamedova, Kavkazskaya Albaniya i Albantsy. Center for Research on Caucasian Albania, Baku, 2005 (in Russian).
R.H. Hewsen, Ethno-history and the Armenian influence upon the Caucasian Albanians, in: T.J. Samuelian (ed.), Classical Armenian Culture, Influence and creativity. Scholars Press, 1982, 26-40. Available at: https://archive.org/details/hewsen-1982-armenia-aghuania/mode/2up. Accessed on April 12, 2024.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Manushak Titanian
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial (CC BY-NC). CC BY-NC allows users to copy and distribute the article, provided this is not done for commercial purposes. The users may adapt – remix, transform, and build upon the material giving appropriate credit, providing a link to the license. The full details of the license are available at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.